Why “You’re Doing a Great Job. Keep it Up!” May Be the Worst Feedback You Can Get

In my recent work with business leaders, three of them shared feedback with me that they had received from their boss as part of their annual performance appraisal process. Instead of a 30-60 minute assessment of their prior year’s performance, each of them instead heard something like “You’re doing a great job. Keep it up!” or “I loved your self-assessment. I totally agree.” And these weren’t 30-60 minute conversations. It was 5 minutes.

At first blush, it sounds great! Each of my clients were thrilled to receive positive and supportive feedback from their boss. Yet, in the long-term, this may be the worst feedback you can get during a performance assessment.

Continued Growth

Why? Because folks need to hear what they’re doing well and what they need to do differently in order to continue to grow. If all you hear is “You’re doing a great job. Keep it up!” you are not hearing everything that you need to hear in order to grow. You’re not hearing the imperfections that you need to hear in order to make progress.

If you work at an organization that implements an annual performance assessment, your assessment must be comprised of three segments:

  1. How you did on your prior year’s performance expectations, goals, and objectives. This includes good and bad observations – what went right or wrong? No one is perfect and imperfections provide room for growth.
  2. What you could do differently in the months to come to have an increasingly positive impact.
  3. How your boss can help.

That’s it. Any assessment that is more future-focused than past-focused is more likely to help you get the feedback you need in order to grow and evolve.

Image by mohamed Hassan from Pixabay


Raise Your Visibility & Value: Uncover the Lost Art of Connecting on the Job is available

in AUDIO FORMAT here on Amazon and iTunes

and in HARD COPY here on Amazon and Barnes & Noble.